【情侶雙亡】馬自達男坦承趕時間時速80 - 開車
By Jake
at 2020-12-23T10:48
at 2020-12-23T10:48
Table of Contents
※ 引述《wisdom ()》之銘言:
: 總之,我的看法是馬自達無責,超速與事故無因果關係,未注意車前狀況不成立(猝不及
: 防)。
: 以上鍵盤。
本篇說明其實很合理,
底下推文很多人糾結在被告本身既然違規,怎麼可能無過失,
但事實上刑法上的過失是以結果論,
並不單純是「你這個行為有過失」,
而是「對於這個結果來說,你是有過失的」,
意思就是,抽離掉結果,行為本身的違規、不注意等等,沒什麼意義,
例如你闖紅燈,結果闖完沒發生任何事情,那你有沒有過失?沒有。
沒有「結果」,就沒有過失,頂多就是很危險要開罰單。
而既然要講結果,就不能忽略行為與結果的關聯性,也就是因果關係,
雖然你做了一件錯事,但如果你沒做錯,還是會發生一樣的結果,
那就會認為你這個錯事跟結果沒有因果關係,那也就「沒有過失」。
最常舉的例子是酒駕肇事,
某甲酒駕,酒測值超標,在路口等紅燈時,
一個開車睡著的人從後方高速追撞,撞死了,
此時酒駕者有沒有違規?有,甚至還有酒駕的刑責,
但他對於「後車駕駛死亡的結果」有沒有過失?
沒有。
推文也有很多人質疑法院不會這樣判,
雖然我也無法保證法官一定會怎麼判,
但實際上過去確實有類似的案件判無罪的,
舉例而言
https://tw.appledaily.com/local/20180625/MR5AVQHJU5KETX4BIXPKTRNYCU/
這是100年間的車禍案件,
速限30的施工路段,被告以時速60-90間的速度超速行駛,
撞上從巷口闖紅燈駛出的三貼機車,
媽媽重傷癱瘓,兒女一死一傷。
本案車禍鑑定委員會、交通大學鑑定,都認定被告無過失,
此外還送逢甲大學鑑定,也認定被告縱使依照速限行駛,仍無法及時煞車。
但是逢甲大學另外提出一個論點,
就是「若被告依速限30公里行駛,會晚一點到達路口,可以避開告訴人的機車」,
然而,這在學理上稱為「假設的因果關係」,
但一個事件發生,伴隨的因素太多了,不可能一一假設,
假設被告前面都用90公里超速行駛,因此提早抵達路口,
但抵達路口時已經降速到30公里呢?
結果還是會剛好遇到被害人闖紅燈,還是煞車不及,那又如何認定?
若要這樣假設,那永遠假設不完,
而且不得超速規定,是要避免超速導致反應不及的車禍事故,
並不是要避免超速可能導致兩車可能同時抵達路口的巧合發生,
所以這種假設因果關係是不被採納的,
(後來即使二審改判有罪,也沒有採納此論點)
一審最後判決被告無罪。
臺灣新北地方法院 106 年交易字第 7 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/MdqdlX
案件到了二審,逆轉改判被告有罪,
採用的理由類似上一篇推文有提到的論點,
認為被告既然超速,就不能主張信賴原則,
也就是他不能「相信別人不會闖紅燈」,
則被害人闖紅燈從巷口衝出來,你也要預先防範,誰叫你要超速,
最後二審以過失致死罪,判被告6月徒刑,得易科罰金(換算約18萬元)
臺灣高等法院 107 年交上易字第 323 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/Oq9qx7
案件到了最高法院,把原判決撤銷發回,
理由說得非常清楚:
「刑法上之無認識過失,係指對於構成犯罪之事實,按其情節
應注意,並能注意,而不注意者而言。故行為人何以有能注
意之情事,當有調查並說明清楚之必要。原判決係認定上訴
人因超速行駛而就事件之發生有過失。故判斷上,應以上訴
人發現賴心怡之機車時,若未超速行駛(速限30公里),能
否有充足之停車距離以避免本件事故發生,作為認定其是否
「能注意」之標準。」
最高法院 109 年台上字第 955 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/n0e0W1
案件回到高等法院,維持一審無罪判決,
理由就跟先前論點一樣
「被告縱未違規超速行駛,而係以時速30公里行進,亦無足夠反
應距離及煞車距離,而得採取必要之安全措施以避免事故發生
,則被告雖有超速行駛之違規行為,然亦無從注意而避免本案
發生,自難認有駕車過失行為。」
臺灣高等法院 109 年交上更一字第 6 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/Y6yWO0
本案不得上訴,就此確定。
我並沒有說法官這樣判一定對,也沒有說本案一定也會這樣判,
但至少這個論點,司法實務上確實是可能被採納的,
況且連最高法院都表示意見,那未來下級法院遵循的機率是很高的,
給各位參考,大家也可以持續關注未來本案會怎麼下判決。
--
: 總之,我的看法是馬自達無責,超速與事故無因果關係,未注意車前狀況不成立(猝不及
: 防)。
: 以上鍵盤。
本篇說明其實很合理,
底下推文很多人糾結在被告本身既然違規,怎麼可能無過失,
但事實上刑法上的過失是以結果論,
並不單純是「你這個行為有過失」,
而是「對於這個結果來說,你是有過失的」,
意思就是,抽離掉結果,行為本身的違規、不注意等等,沒什麼意義,
例如你闖紅燈,結果闖完沒發生任何事情,那你有沒有過失?沒有。
沒有「結果」,就沒有過失,頂多就是很危險要開罰單。
而既然要講結果,就不能忽略行為與結果的關聯性,也就是因果關係,
雖然你做了一件錯事,但如果你沒做錯,還是會發生一樣的結果,
那就會認為你這個錯事跟結果沒有因果關係,那也就「沒有過失」。
最常舉的例子是酒駕肇事,
某甲酒駕,酒測值超標,在路口等紅燈時,
一個開車睡著的人從後方高速追撞,撞死了,
此時酒駕者有沒有違規?有,甚至還有酒駕的刑責,
但他對於「後車駕駛死亡的結果」有沒有過失?
沒有。
推文也有很多人質疑法院不會這樣判,
雖然我也無法保證法官一定會怎麼判,
但實際上過去確實有類似的案件判無罪的,
舉例而言
https://tw.appledaily.com/local/20180625/MR5AVQHJU5KETX4BIXPKTRNYCU/
這是100年間的車禍案件,
速限30的施工路段,被告以時速60-90間的速度超速行駛,
撞上從巷口闖紅燈駛出的三貼機車,
媽媽重傷癱瘓,兒女一死一傷。
本案車禍鑑定委員會、交通大學鑑定,都認定被告無過失,
此外還送逢甲大學鑑定,也認定被告縱使依照速限行駛,仍無法及時煞車。
但是逢甲大學另外提出一個論點,
就是「若被告依速限30公里行駛,會晚一點到達路口,可以避開告訴人的機車」,
然而,這在學理上稱為「假設的因果關係」,
但一個事件發生,伴隨的因素太多了,不可能一一假設,
假設被告前面都用90公里超速行駛,因此提早抵達路口,
但抵達路口時已經降速到30公里呢?
結果還是會剛好遇到被害人闖紅燈,還是煞車不及,那又如何認定?
若要這樣假設,那永遠假設不完,
而且不得超速規定,是要避免超速導致反應不及的車禍事故,
並不是要避免超速可能導致兩車可能同時抵達路口的巧合發生,
所以這種假設因果關係是不被採納的,
(後來即使二審改判有罪,也沒有採納此論點)
一審最後判決被告無罪。
臺灣新北地方法院 106 年交易字第 7 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/MdqdlX
案件到了二審,逆轉改判被告有罪,
採用的理由類似上一篇推文有提到的論點,
認為被告既然超速,就不能主張信賴原則,
也就是他不能「相信別人不會闖紅燈」,
則被害人闖紅燈從巷口衝出來,你也要預先防範,誰叫你要超速,
最後二審以過失致死罪,判被告6月徒刑,得易科罰金(換算約18萬元)
臺灣高等法院 107 年交上易字第 323 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/Oq9qx7
案件到了最高法院,把原判決撤銷發回,
理由說得非常清楚:
「刑法上之無認識過失,係指對於構成犯罪之事實,按其情節
應注意,並能注意,而不注意者而言。故行為人何以有能注
意之情事,當有調查並說明清楚之必要。原判決係認定上訴
人因超速行駛而就事件之發生有過失。故判斷上,應以上訴
人發現賴心怡之機車時,若未超速行駛(速限30公里),能
否有充足之停車距離以避免本件事故發生,作為認定其是否
「能注意」之標準。」
最高法院 109 年台上字第 955 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/n0e0W1
案件回到高等法院,維持一審無罪判決,
理由就跟先前論點一樣
「被告縱未違規超速行駛,而係以時速30公里行進,亦無足夠反
應距離及煞車距離,而得採取必要之安全措施以避免事故發生
,則被告雖有超速行駛之違規行為,然亦無從注意而避免本案
發生,自難認有駕車過失行為。」
臺灣高等法院 109 年交上更一字第 6 號刑事判決
https://reurl.cc/Y6yWO0
本案不得上訴,就此確定。
我並沒有說法官這樣判一定對,也沒有說本案一定也會這樣判,
但至少這個論點,司法實務上確實是可能被採納的,
況且連最高法院都表示意見,那未來下級法院遵循的機率是很高的,
給各位參考,大家也可以持續關注未來本案會怎麼下判決。
--
Tags:
開車
All Comments
By Tristan Cohan
at 2020-12-26T12:04
at 2020-12-26T12:04
By Linda
at 2020-12-26T18:02
at 2020-12-26T18:02
By Michael
at 2020-12-30T03:52
at 2020-12-30T03:52
By Blanche
at 2020-12-30T13:08
at 2020-12-30T13:08
By Olga
at 2021-01-03T22:44
at 2021-01-03T22:44
By Noah
at 2021-01-05T10:32
at 2021-01-05T10:32
By Lauren
at 2021-01-05T22:36
at 2021-01-05T22:36
By David
at 2021-01-08T00:19
at 2021-01-08T00:19
By Thomas
at 2021-01-12T08:14
at 2021-01-12T08:14
By Lily
at 2021-01-16T05:17
at 2021-01-16T05:17
By Elizabeth
at 2021-01-16T12:16
at 2021-01-16T12:16
By Blanche
at 2021-01-16T15:48
at 2021-01-16T15:48
By Yedda
at 2021-01-20T18:25
at 2021-01-20T18:25
By Eden
at 2021-01-23T04:42
at 2021-01-23T04:42
By Lily
at 2021-01-25T19:49
at 2021-01-25T19:49
By Edith
at 2021-01-29T04:29
at 2021-01-29T04:29
By Damian
at 2021-01-29T22:51
at 2021-01-29T22:51
By Enid
at 2021-02-01T10:35
at 2021-02-01T10:35
By Connor
at 2021-02-04T08:09
at 2021-02-04T08:09
By Lucy
at 2021-02-05T01:33
at 2021-02-05T01:33
By Agatha
at 2021-02-07T21:22
at 2021-02-07T21:22
By Hamiltion
at 2021-02-12T00:18
at 2021-02-12T00:18
By Elizabeth
at 2021-02-14T16:52
at 2021-02-14T16:52
By Ethan
at 2021-02-14T18:03
at 2021-02-14T18:03
By Jessica
at 2021-02-14T19:20
at 2021-02-14T19:20
By Olga
at 2021-02-17T10:02
at 2021-02-17T10:02
By Queena
at 2021-02-20T08:21
at 2021-02-20T08:21
By James
at 2021-02-21T00:00
at 2021-02-21T00:00
By Callum
at 2021-02-23T15:50
at 2021-02-23T15:50
By Carolina Franco
at 2021-02-23T20:54
at 2021-02-23T20:54
By Zora
at 2021-02-28T05:42
at 2021-02-28T05:42
By Carol
at 2021-03-01T19:33
at 2021-03-01T19:33
By Noah
at 2021-03-04T18:15
at 2021-03-04T18:15
By Steve
at 2021-03-07T13:37
at 2021-03-07T13:37
By Lydia
at 2021-03-10T01:06
at 2021-03-10T01:06
By Brianna
at 2021-03-13T14:20
at 2021-03-13T14:20
By Emma
at 2021-03-16T15:12
at 2021-03-16T15:12
By Lily
at 2021-03-20T14:30
at 2021-03-20T14:30
By Necoo
at 2021-03-22T10:07
at 2021-03-22T10:07
By Connor
at 2021-03-24T00:08
at 2021-03-24T00:08
By Vanessa
at 2021-03-24T03:20
at 2021-03-24T03:20
By Freda
at 2021-03-28T10:04
at 2021-03-28T10:04
By Jacob
at 2021-03-30T14:53
at 2021-03-30T14:53
By Belly
at 2021-04-02T16:40
at 2021-04-02T16:40
By Robert
at 2021-04-04T08:28
at 2021-04-04T08:28
By Gilbert
at 2021-04-06T03:09
at 2021-04-06T03:09
By Franklin
at 2021-04-09T19:52
at 2021-04-09T19:52
By Kristin
at 2021-04-13T04:26
at 2021-04-13T04:26
By Lydia
at 2021-04-16T20:19
at 2021-04-16T20:19
By Victoria
at 2021-04-21T12:19
at 2021-04-21T12:19
By Rosalind
at 2021-04-23T18:11
at 2021-04-23T18:11
By Todd Johnson
at 2021-04-26T03:03
at 2021-04-26T03:03
By Dora
at 2021-04-30T04:45
at 2021-04-30T04:45
By Belly
at 2021-04-30T14:04
at 2021-04-30T14:04
By Iris
at 2021-05-01T21:08
at 2021-05-01T21:08
By Andrew
at 2021-05-05T20:22
at 2021-05-05T20:22
By Tom
at 2021-05-07T05:16
at 2021-05-07T05:16
By Jake
at 2021-05-08T06:53
at 2021-05-08T06:53
By Blanche
at 2021-05-09T01:18
at 2021-05-09T01:18
By Odelette
at 2021-05-11T14:40
at 2021-05-11T14:40
By Kumar
at 2021-05-14T11:20
at 2021-05-14T11:20
By Annie
at 2021-05-17T22:08
at 2021-05-17T22:08
By Irma
at 2021-05-21T07:53
at 2021-05-21T07:53
By Daniel
at 2021-05-22T22:04
at 2021-05-22T22:04
By David
at 2021-05-25T18:21
at 2021-05-25T18:21
By Olivia
at 2021-05-29T02:11
at 2021-05-29T02:11
By Edwina
at 2021-05-29T09:55
at 2021-05-29T09:55
By Joseph
at 2021-05-30T05:09
at 2021-05-30T05:09
By Emma
at 2021-06-03T03:47
at 2021-06-03T03:47
By Mason
at 2021-06-03T23:22
at 2021-06-03T23:22
By Regina
at 2021-06-07T01:57
at 2021-06-07T01:57
By Todd Johnson
at 2021-06-08T19:25
at 2021-06-08T19:25
By Damian
at 2021-06-10T06:14
at 2021-06-10T06:14
By Lucy
at 2021-06-13T06:16
at 2021-06-13T06:16
By Elizabeth
at 2021-06-17T13:03
at 2021-06-17T13:03
By Sarah
at 2021-06-20T22:32
at 2021-06-20T22:32
By Rebecca
at 2021-06-23T21:58
at 2021-06-23T21:58
By Skylar Davis
at 2021-06-25T23:47
at 2021-06-25T23:47
By Una
at 2021-06-29T22:07
at 2021-06-29T22:07
By Ursula
at 2021-07-04T10:08
at 2021-07-04T10:08
By Ursula
at 2021-07-06T20:42
at 2021-07-06T20:42
By Eden
at 2021-07-07T19:03
at 2021-07-07T19:03
By Suhail Hany
at 2021-07-10T13:32
at 2021-07-10T13:32
By Olivia
at 2021-07-15T03:24
at 2021-07-15T03:24
By Charlotte
at 2021-07-19T21:05
at 2021-07-19T21:05
By Zora
at 2021-07-20T08:49
at 2021-07-20T08:49
By Poppy
at 2021-07-23T11:11
at 2021-07-23T11:11
By Jacob
at 2021-07-26T11:14
at 2021-07-26T11:14
By Iris
at 2021-07-27T07:20
at 2021-07-27T07:20
By Audriana
at 2021-07-29T04:55
at 2021-07-29T04:55
By Eden
at 2021-08-02T07:34
at 2021-08-02T07:34
By Regina
at 2021-08-05T15:42
at 2021-08-05T15:42
By Dora
at 2021-08-10T04:50
at 2021-08-10T04:50
By Ingrid
at 2021-08-14T12:31
at 2021-08-14T12:31
By Olivia
at 2021-08-17T02:57
at 2021-08-17T02:57
By Kyle
at 2021-08-19T08:12
at 2021-08-19T08:12
By Isla
at 2021-08-22T06:38
at 2021-08-22T06:38
By Frederica
at 2021-08-25T10:47
at 2021-08-25T10:47
By Harry
at 2021-08-26T12:48
at 2021-08-26T12:48
By Elizabeth
at 2021-08-30T03:13
at 2021-08-30T03:13
By Carol
at 2021-08-31T21:37
at 2021-08-31T21:37
By George
at 2021-09-04T01:24
at 2021-09-04T01:24
By Ivy
at 2021-09-04T04:54
at 2021-09-04T04:54
By Skylar DavisLinda
at 2021-09-06T21:21
at 2021-09-06T21:21
By Delia
at 2021-09-10T18:36
at 2021-09-10T18:36
By Kyle
at 2021-09-13T03:51
at 2021-09-13T03:51
By Harry
at 2021-09-17T14:29
at 2021-09-17T14:29
By Andrew
at 2021-09-22T07:02
at 2021-09-22T07:02
By Andrew
at 2021-09-22T08:45
at 2021-09-22T08:45
By Edith
at 2021-09-26T20:21
at 2021-09-26T20:21
By Anthony
at 2021-10-01T07:11
at 2021-10-01T07:11
By Todd Johnson
at 2021-10-05T00:55
at 2021-10-05T00:55
By Jessica
at 2021-10-05T04:55
at 2021-10-05T04:55
By Lydia
at 2021-10-05T09:53
at 2021-10-05T09:53
By Sarah
at 2021-10-06T11:38
at 2021-10-06T11:38
By Xanthe
at 2021-10-10T02:44
at 2021-10-10T02:44
By Rachel
at 2021-10-12T22:10
at 2021-10-12T22:10
By William
at 2021-10-16T22:00
at 2021-10-16T22:00
By Doris
at 2021-10-21T12:21
at 2021-10-21T12:21
By Daniel
at 2021-10-25T22:33
at 2021-10-25T22:33
By Eartha
at 2021-10-30T01:32
at 2021-10-30T01:32
By Ula
at 2021-10-31T07:13
at 2021-10-31T07:13
By Genevieve
at 2021-11-04T18:14
at 2021-11-04T18:14
By Ophelia
at 2021-11-06T01:35
at 2021-11-06T01:35
By Dorothy
at 2021-11-07T14:18
at 2021-11-07T14:18
By Michael
at 2021-11-11T11:53
at 2021-11-11T11:53
By Zanna
at 2021-11-13T08:27
at 2021-11-13T08:27
By Genevieve
at 2021-11-16T09:56
at 2021-11-16T09:56
By Emma
at 2021-11-18T07:15
at 2021-11-18T07:15
By Irma
at 2021-11-21T11:22
at 2021-11-21T11:22
By Anonymous
at 2021-11-25T12:55
at 2021-11-25T12:55
By Oscar
at 2021-11-29T10:36
at 2021-11-29T10:36
By Frederica
at 2021-12-02T15:36
at 2021-12-02T15:36
By Michael
at 2021-12-04T08:29
at 2021-12-04T08:29
By James
at 2021-12-06T22:29
at 2021-12-06T22:29
By Todd Johnson
at 2021-12-09T15:57
at 2021-12-09T15:57
By Delia
at 2021-12-10T00:09
at 2021-12-10T00:09
By Vanessa
at 2021-12-14T03:50
at 2021-12-14T03:50
By Dorothy
at 2021-12-17T06:36
at 2021-12-17T06:36
By Necoo
at 2021-12-17T19:17
at 2021-12-17T19:17
By Necoo
at 2021-12-18T18:44
at 2021-12-18T18:44
By Edith
at 2021-12-21T16:09
at 2021-12-21T16:09
By Gilbert
at 2021-12-23T05:47
at 2021-12-23T05:47
By Eden
at 2021-12-23T12:22
at 2021-12-23T12:22
By Jacob
at 2021-12-24T07:05
at 2021-12-24T07:05
By Connor
at 2021-12-24T08:25
at 2021-12-24T08:25
By Emily
at 2021-12-28T05:58
at 2021-12-28T05:58
By Hamiltion
at 2021-12-28T13:35
at 2021-12-28T13:35
By Ethan
at 2022-01-02T03:47
at 2022-01-02T03:47
By Tristan Cohan
at 2022-01-05T04:53
at 2022-01-05T04:53
By Megan
at 2022-01-09T20:20
at 2022-01-09T20:20
By Ursula
at 2022-01-12T13:13
at 2022-01-12T13:13
By Andrew
at 2022-01-13T05:43
at 2022-01-13T05:43
By Madame
at 2022-01-16T19:39
at 2022-01-16T19:39
By Hardy
at 2022-01-18T09:07
at 2022-01-18T09:07
By Poppy
at 2022-01-22T22:58
at 2022-01-22T22:58
By Iris
at 2022-01-25T17:11
at 2022-01-25T17:11
By Donna
at 2022-01-29T12:35
at 2022-01-29T12:35
By Audriana
at 2022-02-01T23:47
at 2022-02-01T23:47
By Mason
at 2022-02-03T10:19
at 2022-02-03T10:19
By Tracy
at 2022-02-03T23:56
at 2022-02-03T23:56
By Elma
at 2022-02-06T13:11
at 2022-02-06T13:11
By Christine
at 2022-02-10T06:47
at 2022-02-10T06:47
By Hamiltion
at 2022-02-14T16:25
at 2022-02-14T16:25
By Edith
at 2022-02-17T11:28
at 2022-02-17T11:28
By Caitlin
at 2022-02-17T12:33
at 2022-02-17T12:33
By Lydia
at 2022-02-20T07:45
at 2022-02-20T07:45
By Selena
at 2022-02-22T21:28
at 2022-02-22T21:28
By Dinah
at 2022-02-25T10:53
at 2022-02-25T10:53
By Candice
at 2022-03-01T20:02
at 2022-03-01T20:02
By Ida
at 2022-03-04T16:24
at 2022-03-04T16:24
By Lydia
at 2022-03-08T18:57
at 2022-03-08T18:57
By Barb Cronin
at 2022-03-11T19:56
at 2022-03-11T19:56
By Quanna
at 2022-03-14T06:04
at 2022-03-14T06:04
By Frederic
at 2022-03-19T04:26
at 2022-03-19T04:26
By Carolina Franco
at 2022-03-19T05:46
at 2022-03-19T05:46
By Candice
at 2022-03-23T12:59
at 2022-03-23T12:59
By Barb Cronin
at 2022-03-24T01:29
at 2022-03-24T01:29
By Xanthe
at 2022-03-25T06:34
at 2022-03-25T06:34
By Isla
at 2022-03-30T02:43
at 2022-03-30T02:43
By Doris
at 2022-04-02T23:09
at 2022-04-02T23:09
By Sandy
at 2022-04-05T08:43
at 2022-04-05T08:43
By Mason
at 2022-04-08T14:55
at 2022-04-08T14:55
By Oscar
at 2022-04-11T17:58
at 2022-04-11T17:58
By Harry
at 2022-04-11T23:30
at 2022-04-11T23:30
By Noah
at 2022-04-12T17:04
at 2022-04-12T17:04
By Edward Lewis
at 2022-04-16T10:26
at 2022-04-16T10:26
By Elvira
at 2022-04-17T19:11
at 2022-04-17T19:11
By Leila
at 2022-04-18T04:37
at 2022-04-18T04:37
By Isabella
at 2022-04-21T08:53
at 2022-04-21T08:53
By Carolina Franco
at 2022-04-26T01:52
at 2022-04-26T01:52
By Genevieve
at 2022-04-27T10:09
at 2022-04-27T10:09
By Charlie
at 2022-05-01T10:23
at 2022-05-01T10:23
By Daph Bay
at 2022-05-04T09:58
at 2022-05-04T09:58
By Frederica
at 2022-05-05T04:40
at 2022-05-05T04:40
By Una
at 2022-05-09T16:58
at 2022-05-09T16:58
By Andy
at 2022-05-13T19:19
at 2022-05-13T19:19
By Hazel
at 2022-05-16T08:20
at 2022-05-16T08:20
By Barb Cronin
at 2022-05-18T02:14
at 2022-05-18T02:14
By Quintina
at 2022-05-20T11:39
at 2022-05-20T11:39
By Ursula
at 2022-05-25T03:40
at 2022-05-25T03:40
By Elma
at 2022-05-25T15:27
at 2022-05-25T15:27
By Selena
at 2022-05-27T09:07
at 2022-05-27T09:07
By Eden
at 2022-06-01T08:14
at 2022-06-01T08:14
By Iris
at 2022-06-02T06:25
at 2022-06-02T06:25
By Elizabeth
at 2022-06-05T06:06
at 2022-06-05T06:06
By Queena
at 2022-06-07T06:41
at 2022-06-07T06:41
By Brianna
at 2022-06-08T02:40
at 2022-06-08T02:40
By Hedwig
at 2022-06-09T13:30
at 2022-06-09T13:30
By Yuri
at 2022-06-13T20:00
at 2022-06-13T20:00
By Victoria
at 2022-06-15T23:33
at 2022-06-15T23:33
By Todd Johnson
at 2022-06-19T15:49
at 2022-06-19T15:49
By Andrew
at 2022-06-23T17:05
at 2022-06-23T17:05
By Lydia
at 2022-06-28T00:54
at 2022-06-28T00:54
By Enid
at 2022-06-28T05:56
at 2022-06-28T05:56
By Queena
at 2022-07-02T04:45
at 2022-07-02T04:45
By Edward Lewis
at 2022-07-04T17:30
at 2022-07-04T17:30
By Carolina Franco
at 2022-07-06T02:43
at 2022-07-06T02:43
By Carolina Franco
at 2022-07-06T11:00
at 2022-07-06T11:00
By Megan
at 2022-07-09T09:38
at 2022-07-09T09:38
By Leila
at 2022-07-11T13:55
at 2022-07-11T13:55
By Elizabeth
at 2022-07-16T10:37
at 2022-07-16T10:37
By Mason
at 2022-07-21T08:08
at 2022-07-21T08:08
By Carolina Franco
at 2022-07-26T03:32
at 2022-07-26T03:32
By Daph Bay
at 2022-07-27T06:47
at 2022-07-27T06:47
By Necoo
at 2022-07-31T12:02
at 2022-07-31T12:02
By Edith
at 2022-08-01T12:51
at 2022-08-01T12:51
By Jessica
at 2022-08-04T08:07
at 2022-08-04T08:07
By Frederica
at 2022-08-05T18:54
at 2022-08-05T18:54
By Frederic
at 2022-08-10T13:15
at 2022-08-10T13:15
By Adele
at 2022-08-15T01:28
at 2022-08-15T01:28
By Bethany
at 2022-08-17T06:55
at 2022-08-17T06:55
By Zenobia
at 2022-08-20T00:05
at 2022-08-20T00:05
By Xanthe
at 2022-08-20T09:16
at 2022-08-20T09:16
By Isla
at 2022-08-24T00:30
at 2022-08-24T00:30
By Hedda
at 2022-08-25T10:43
at 2022-08-25T10:43
By Isabella
at 2022-08-26T18:26
at 2022-08-26T18:26
By Rae
at 2022-08-26T22:37
at 2022-08-26T22:37
By Quintina
at 2022-08-29T07:23
at 2022-08-29T07:23
By Iris
at 2022-09-02T12:07
at 2022-09-02T12:07
By Damian
at 2022-09-03T12:09
at 2022-09-03T12:09
By Jessica
at 2022-09-08T04:03
at 2022-09-08T04:03
By Candice
at 2022-09-12T17:18
at 2022-09-12T17:18
By Jack
at 2022-09-16T23:09
at 2022-09-16T23:09
By Elvira
at 2022-09-18T09:30
at 2022-09-18T09:30
By Belly
at 2022-09-22T07:52
at 2022-09-22T07:52
By Quanna
at 2022-09-25T23:28
at 2022-09-25T23:28
By Ethan
at 2022-09-27T15:45
at 2022-09-27T15:45
By Caroline
at 2022-09-30T14:17
at 2022-09-30T14:17
By Ursula
at 2022-10-04T16:14
at 2022-10-04T16:14
By Hedda
at 2022-10-07T15:34
at 2022-10-07T15:34
By Oscar
at 2022-10-07T23:23
at 2022-10-07T23:23
By Andy
at 2022-10-10T11:24
at 2022-10-10T11:24
By Edward Lewis
at 2022-10-11T22:19
at 2022-10-11T22:19
By Noah
at 2022-10-14T11:10
at 2022-10-14T11:10
By Rae
at 2022-10-17T04:57
at 2022-10-17T04:57
By Erin
at 2022-10-18T03:32
at 2022-10-18T03:32
By Catherine
at 2022-10-23T00:58
at 2022-10-23T00:58
By Emma
at 2022-10-25T07:40
at 2022-10-25T07:40
By Audriana
at 2022-10-29T14:25
at 2022-10-29T14:25
By Jake
at 2022-10-30T10:16
at 2022-10-30T10:16
By Kumar
at 2022-11-01T23:17
at 2022-11-01T23:17
By Wallis
at 2022-11-06T15:00
at 2022-11-06T15:00
By Elma
at 2022-11-10T06:24
at 2022-11-10T06:24
By Edwina
at 2022-11-14T23:22
at 2022-11-14T23:22
By Kyle
at 2022-11-19T16:49
at 2022-11-19T16:49
By Lydia
at 2022-11-22T07:34
at 2022-11-22T07:34
By Ida
at 2022-11-22T21:47
at 2022-11-22T21:47
By Robert
at 2022-11-26T05:52
at 2022-11-26T05:52
By Lucy
at 2022-11-30T06:34
at 2022-11-30T06:34
By Caitlin
at 2022-12-02T08:16
at 2022-12-02T08:16
By Hazel
at 2022-12-03T11:08
at 2022-12-03T11:08
By Jacky
at 2022-12-07T20:09
at 2022-12-07T20:09
By Puput
at 2022-12-12T14:03
at 2022-12-12T14:03
By Lucy
at 2022-12-15T12:00
at 2022-12-15T12:00
By Caroline
at 2022-12-19T09:17
at 2022-12-19T09:17
By Connor
at 2022-12-21T01:33
at 2022-12-21T01:33
By Poppy
at 2022-12-23T00:23
at 2022-12-23T00:23
By Iris
at 2022-12-24T23:10
at 2022-12-24T23:10
By Rosalind
at 2022-12-27T00:25
at 2022-12-27T00:25
By Daniel
at 2022-12-30T20:50
at 2022-12-30T20:50
By Ethan
at 2023-01-01T04:34
at 2023-01-01T04:34
By Bethany
at 2023-01-05T12:47
at 2023-01-05T12:47
By Carol
at 2023-01-06T00:09
at 2023-01-06T00:09
By Edwina
at 2023-01-08T04:51
at 2023-01-08T04:51
By Susan
at 2023-01-11T11:54
at 2023-01-11T11:54
By Una
at 2023-01-12T16:24
at 2023-01-12T16:24
By Una
at 2023-01-17T01:21
at 2023-01-17T01:21
By Hardy
at 2023-01-18T19:09
at 2023-01-18T19:09
By Hardy
at 2023-01-20T18:34
at 2023-01-20T18:34
By Freda
at 2023-01-21T13:10
at 2023-01-21T13:10
By Aaliyah
at 2023-01-25T02:35
at 2023-01-25T02:35
By Selena
at 2023-01-26T23:32
at 2023-01-26T23:32
By Gilbert
at 2023-01-31T07:43
at 2023-01-31T07:43
By Poppy
at 2023-02-05T05:49
at 2023-02-05T05:49
By Dora
at 2023-02-09T20:23
at 2023-02-09T20:23
By Doris
at 2023-02-12T15:54
at 2023-02-12T15:54
By Jacky
at 2023-02-15T05:48
at 2023-02-15T05:48
By Heather
at 2023-02-19T12:17
at 2023-02-19T12:17
By Valerie
at 2023-02-21T08:26
at 2023-02-21T08:26
By Jessica
at 2023-02-22T23:59
at 2023-02-22T23:59
By Erin
at 2023-02-24T16:45
at 2023-02-24T16:45
By Ethan
at 2023-02-26T19:36
at 2023-02-26T19:36
By Jacob
at 2023-02-27T13:30
at 2023-02-27T13:30
By Ivy
at 2023-02-28T12:12
at 2023-02-28T12:12
By Suhail Hany
at 2023-03-01T09:22
at 2023-03-01T09:22
By Candice
at 2023-03-05T02:28
at 2023-03-05T02:28
By Audriana
at 2023-03-07T09:44
at 2023-03-07T09:44
By Ingrid
at 2023-03-11T00:28
at 2023-03-11T00:28
By Puput
at 2023-03-14T16:50
at 2023-03-14T16:50
By Damian
at 2023-03-16T21:59
at 2023-03-16T21:59
By Kristin
at 2023-03-18T21:04
at 2023-03-18T21:04
By Charlotte
at 2023-03-21T23:21
at 2023-03-21T23:21
By Yedda
at 2023-03-23T18:16
at 2023-03-23T18:16
Related Posts
corolla cross汽油尊爵交車心得
By Selena
at 2020-12-23T10:40
at 2020-12-23T10:40
Corolla Cross油電交車分享
By Eden
at 2020-12-22T21:42
at 2020-12-22T21:42
【情侶雙亡】馬自達男坦承趕時間時速80
By Charlotte
at 2020-12-22T16:44
at 2020-12-22T16:44
【情侶雙亡】馬自達男坦承趕時間時速80
By Mason
at 2020-12-22T15:36
at 2020-12-22T15:36
【情侶雙亡】馬自達男坦承趕時間時速80
By Jack
at 2020-12-22T14:00
at 2020-12-22T14:00